Review: Hornady .38 Super Comp Brass

by
posted on May 24, 2017
title-image-hornady1.jpg

Hornady just released a new brass case for .38 Super shooters, this one a rimless .38 Super Comp. Rimless cases are the best design for semi-automatic pistols, and one flaw of the .38 Super is its semi-rim.

null
Figure 1.


The .38 Super is actually the .38 Automatic with a different name. (To be correct, the Super’s name is .38 Super Automatic +P.) The .38 Automatic was created in 1900 by John Browning for his new semi-automatic pistol produced by Colt. Mr. Browning designed the case with a semi-rim, intended to be used for headspacing the cartridge. It might have seemed like a good idea at the time, but the semi-rim was unnecessary and would prove to be less than ideal over time.

When cartridges are stacked in the magazine, the rim of the upper round is positioned in the extractor groove of the underlying round. With the semi-rimmed .38 Super, the rim protrudes farther into the extractor groove than rimless cases like the .45 Auto. The semi-rim greatly increases the amount of force required to strip the top round from the magazine. It actually requires that the underlying rounds be pushed down slightly so the top round can slide forward. The semi-rim also encourages nosedive. A rimless case offers smoother, easier feeding and higher feed angles because of less nosedive.

This is not Hornady’s first rimless .38 Super case. They used to manufacture the rimless .38 TJ (Todd Jarrett) cases which also had a special extractor groove geometry. Hornady does not make the .38 TJ cases at present, though Starline does.

The .38 Super Comp has been around a while and is produced by Starline. The Starline Super Comp case is not truly rimless, and sports a mini-rim. The rim measures 0.386-inch while the case body is 0.380-inch. It’s small, but it’s there. Hornady has duplicated this mini-rim in their design. The extractor groove geometry of the Hornady Super Comp and Starline cases look the same.

null
Table 1. Case measurements of Hornady and Starline .38 Super Comp cases. A Remington semi-rimmed case was included for comparison.


Case capacity of the new Hornady case was measured and compared to Starline cases. I used the fine grained Accurate #5 powder for this comparison. It has a bulk density of 0.990 grams per cubic centimeter, which is nearly the same as water (water = 1.0 gram / cc). The Hornady case has slightly more capacity than the Starline, holding 0.2-grains more powder.

Case wall thickness at various depths will determine what weight/length of bullets can be used without excessive bulging that would prevent the round from fitting in the chamber. The Hornady brass will accept heavy bullets at nominal overall lengths. I was able to seat 160-grain cast round nose bullets to 1.265-inch and a 170-grain Sierra FMJ .357 bullet to 1.280-inch without excess bulging of the case wall. I did see a measurable bulge when seating a 180-grain Nosler .357 JFP bullet at 1.245-inch. It still fit in my chamber, but it had a 0.002-inch bulge at the base of the bullet.

null
Figure 2. Long and heavy bullets in Hornady .38 Super Comp cases. The 160- and 170-grain bullets fit with no excess bulging, but the 180-grain bullet had a measurable bulge at the base of the bullet.


The rimless .38 Super Comp is a distinct improvement over the semi-rimmed design, and Hornady’s high quality cases will be welcomed by .38 Super shooters everywhere. The suggested retail price is $80.35 per 200. A quick Google search located the new Hornady brass at MidwayUSA, Grafs and Midsouth Shooters Supply at discounted prices.

All figures by the author.

Latest

Chapuis Beretta 1
Chapuis Beretta 1

Chapuis Armes Exhibition At Dallas Beretta Gallery

Chapuis Armes is a French manufacturer of high-end shotguns and rifles

2022 Grand American: Team Fiocchi’s Richard Marshall Secures 21 Trophies

Richard Marshall wins big at 2022 Grand American World Trapshooting Championship

Smith & Wesson M&P380 Shield EZ: The Perfect Teaching Pistol?

Smith & Wesson’s mid-sized M&P380 Shield EZ has the perfect features for introducing students to the world of pistol shooting

Team Winchester’s Kim Rhode, Dania Vizzi Finish Strong At USA Shooting Shotgun National Championships

Team Winchester shooters Kim Rhode and Dania Vizzi shine at 2022 USA Shooting Shotgun Nationals

DC Project’s Dianna Muller On ‘Impactful’ Capitol Hill Visit: ‘We Built Bridges’

Last week, the DC Project returned to Washington, D.C., to share its pro-Second Amendment message on Capitol Hill

USA Clay Target League: 13,214 Competitors Participating In 2022 Fall Season

With more than 13,000 competitors registered, the USA Clay Target League said it has broken the participation record

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Sports USA delivered to your inbox.